REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA 
(GAUTENG LOCAL DIVISION, JOHANNESBURG) 

CASE NO: 41375/2013

DELETE WHICHEVER IS NOT APPLICABLE

(1)	REPORTABLE: YES/NO
(2)	OF INTEREST TO OTHER JUDGES: YES/NO
(3)	REVISED

_________________		________________________
DATE				SIGNATURE

In the matter between: 

CHANGING TIDES 17 (PTY) LTD		 				Applicant

and 

MANGOLELE, FREEDOM AMUKELANI	 		          First Respondent 

SIBEKO, KGOMOTSO PENELOPE 				     Second Respondent

NHLAPHO, NATHAN GIFT 					         Third Respondent

NHLAPHO, JOHANNA NGWANA-MONANA 			       Fourth Respondent		

JUDGMENT  

CAMBANIS AJ: 

[1]	This is an application for leave to appeal the judgment of this matter handed down on 22nd September 2017. 

[2]	Both parties furnished this court with written heads of argument containing detailed analysis of the judgment.  I am indeed indebted to both counsel for their thoughtful assistance in this regard.  In addition, counsel tendered lengthy oral argument in amplification of their heads of argument.

[3]	I have taken all the above into consideration and have carefully considered the arguments and I accordingly make the following order:- 

1.	The petition for leave to appeal is dismissed with costs on an attorney client scale. 

________________________

JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA 
GAUTENG LOCAL DIVISION 
JOHANNESBURG 

Counsel for the Applicant:   
Instructed by:			Unknown  

Counsel for the Respondent:   
Instructed by:			A W Pullinger  

Date of Hearing:			31 July 2017 
Date of Judgment:  			22 September 2017